Readers Write: Possible ritual killing story not credible, not helpful

The Island Now

When I read the headline, “Temples’ possible ritual killing of roosters panned,” I thought I’d mistakenly picked up an old copy of an April Fools edition of your paper.  

Although I thought it was in bad taste, I know April Fools editions often err in that way, and because Jews are preparing for their holiest times in the year, I thought your thinking erred as well but that you figured it appropriate.

Unfortunately, as I read on, I realized you were serious.  

The first paragraph used the words “accused,” “inhumane” and “outdated.”  

Your second paragraph went on to name the “inhumane” temples so “accused.” 

Your third paragraph actually quoted and named the accuser.  

How amazing that an email from one person which usually would be published in your opinion section, be considered so newsworthy as to be given such prominence on your front page.  

As I kept reading, I discovered that both Kings Point and Great Neck have laws prohibiting the keeping of live chickens and, therefore, possibly the temples that participate in this ritual would also be breaking the law. 

I don’t take this defamation lightly.  It is dangerous.  

The United States is very divided now, especially over the Iran agreement.  

Actually, one of your contributors to your opinion column has called to question the motives of those against the Iran agreement suggesting “it appears the emphasis of those opposed is not what may be best for America but what is best for Israel.” 

I am Jewish and opposed to the Iran agreement and I consider myself a patriotic American. 

I am opposed not because of Israel but because I am old enough to remember the British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, after returning from an agreement with Hitler, proclaiming “Peace in our Time.” 

That agreement led to World War II and the killing of millions of soldiers and civilians. 

Roosters and Iran deals may at first seem unrelated but these are days when slogans and accusations are being flung around carelessly and lead to serious misunderstandings.  

I believe you, as editor, and your newspaper practice the pursuit of knowledge and peace and I urge you to publish an apology to the two temples (of which I am not a member) that you have misrepresented. 

The media has the power to divide or enlighten. 

I look forward to your comments.

Myra Breakstone

Great Neck

Share this Article