Readers Write: There is no better deal with Iran on nukes

The Island Now

On Thursday, Aug. 6, the Unitarian Universalist Congregation at Shelter Rock in Manhasset commemorated the 70th anniversary of the U.S. atomic bombing of Hiroshima. Great Neck SANE/Peace Action, Long Island Alliance for Peaceful Alternatives and the Social Action Committee of the congregation sponsored an evening of remembrance, resistance and engagement.

Ironically, it coincided with the discussion raging around the support by the U.S. Congress of the Iran nuclear deal. President Obama spoke to the nation urging acceptance of this historic accord. If it is rejected, it is clear that if we choose to go it alone, the nations who joined us in negotiating the terms will end their participation. 

It is not perfect, but if it is supported by our five partners in the deal and approved by 90  other nations, realistically there is no “better deal”.

In brief, it guarantees a 96 percent reduction of enriched uranium. Iran will have to cut the number of centrifuges by two-thirds, designing and testing or warheads is banned. It provides a strong inspection regime to prevent Iran from cheating. 

Sanctions that have crippled Iran’s economy will be lifted over time as Iran complies with the agreement.

No matter how much we may distrust Iran, to quote President Reagan when we forged another deal that was unpopular, “trust but verify” and sophisticated technology makes it possible to inspect and verify. 

Does anyone doubt that an attack on Israel by Iran would not result in a disastrous retaliation?

No matter how often we hear Iran’s oft-repeated threat to destroy Israel, if they have not done it up to now, such an attempt would be catastrophic for Iran.

We must transmit to those who are so fearful of the loss of an election that we will understand the lack of courage they display. 

By now, they must accept that we are sick and tired of war. How much support would we give to such an alternative?  We have had enough of going it alone and must make this very plain to those who suggest it.

Esther Confino

New Hyde Park

Share this Article