Readers Write: Criticism of Muslims, Mexicans warranted


I am writing this article in response to a column in the Friday, July 29, 2016 issue of the Roslyn Times.  
It was composed by Mr. Jerry Kremer. It was highly critical of Donald Trump.
Mr. Kremer’s first criticism regards an accusation that Donald Trump is an isolationist, just because his campaign theme is “America First.”  
At this point in history, I applaud “America First.”  
I want resistance to the globalist types who want to erase all national borders.  This has been explicitly said to be the goal by the Open Society Foundation funded by George Soros.
One of the reasons World War I was fought was so various people could have a feeling of nationhood and belonging.   
They did not want to be some small segment of a larger empire; at that time the Romanov, Austrian, Hohenzollern, and Ottoman empires.
Well, I have no interest in being part of some new “globalist new world order” empire either.  
I think most Americans agree with me.  To call this isolationist is mendacious.
Mr. Kremer takes umbrage at the fact that Mr. Trump made disparaging remarks about Muslims and Mexicans.  
To begin with, Mr. Trump is not a politician.  He only entered the political arena one year ago.  
He does not have handlers and advisers who groomed him for decades in the art of the political double speak to hide their true agendas.  Mr. Trump may not be that articulate.  But not being articulate does not make one wrong or stupid.
Whether Mr. Kremer wants to admit it or not, Islam is not just a religion.  
Like Communism, it is a totalitarian ideology.  It seeks to control every aspect of your life i.e. your sex life, the music you listen too, the books you read, etc.
Like Communism, it believes the personal is the political.  
As someone who has done some serious genealogy, I have come across immigration papers from 100 years ago.  
One of the questions they asked new immigrants at that time was whether or not they were “anarchists.”  
If you said “no,” and it was later found out that you were an anarchist, then you would be deported.  
I want Muslims to be vetted. I want to know if they will violate the civil rights of other groups in the U.S. (like they violated the civil rights of peaceful Christians marching in Flint, Mich.).  
I want them to answer as to whether or not they believe in Sharia law.  
Sharia law is incompatible with individual rights and the formation of a Republic.  
Anyone believing in it should be refused entry to this country.  
If Mr. Kremer disagrees, then let him explicitly tell us what he would like to do with Sharia Law proponents.  
As for Mexicans, Mr. Trump is correct as well.
Rape is endemic in Mexico.  
Remember last year, there was this outrageous gang rape in India, where the perpetrators not only raped the girl, but then proceeded to mutilate her.  
Indian women, as passive as they are, took to the streets in justifiable anger and protest.  
Well guess what!  The rate of rape in Mexico is higher than that of India.  
Child rape is especially pronounced  (see  
Latin American girls, trekking through Mexico to reach the U.S. border, take birth control pills as a precaution since they expect to be raped.  
Rape is not the only crime.  Illegal immigrants commit disproportionate levels of homicide, kidnaping and drug dealing.   
In addition, not allowing border security is a direct attack on the sovereignty of the United States.  
Does Mr. Kremer believe the U.S. has no right to build a wall?
I should add that I am married to an immigrant.  
She went through all the proper legal channels.  Her fellow immigrant friends were law abiding.  
When their visas expired, they left the country.  This sometimes meant giving up job opportunities or the breaking of romances.  
Those people that would allow illegal immigration are contemptible.  They make saps and suckers out of law abiding people for following the rules.  
Those who promote sanctuary cities and in state tuition for illegals might have a warped, grandiose, self-image that they represent some kind of “underground railroad” akin to that during the Civil War.  
In fact, they are, accessories to criminal acts and cruelly insensitive to the feelings of law abiding people.
Mr. Kremer complains that Donald Trump never disavowed the appeal of the Ku Klux Klan.  
I did not notice any Klan flags at the RNC.  
In contrast, Hiillary Clinton never disavowed the appeal of Bernie Sanders communists.  
They paraded at the DNC with the hammer and sickly proudly waving.  The communists killed exponentially more people than the Klan ever did.
Mr Kremer then proceeds to make the outright lie that coal use is declining throughout the world.  
This was to mock Trump’s appeal to bring back coal jobs to West Virginia.  
China has built 155 new coal plants and Japan is in the process of building 43 ( to replace the loss of energy at the Fukushima nuclear plant during the tsunami).
The U.S. has built none.  If that lie wasn’t big enough, he then proceeds to say that most of the new steel production plants are in the United States.  
Japan produces more steel than we do and China produces about five times as much as what we do.  
That is where most of the steel making plants are.
Besides, steel and coal jobs are not the only losses to our economy.  
Thousands of other manufacturing facilities in the rust belt states have been lost , i.e. TVs, computers, shoes, garments, etc.
I noticed Mr. Kremer avoided addressing these facts.
Lastly, Mr.Trump never praised Saddam Hussein.  
He just acknowledged that he did the world a favor by executing terrorists.  
I remember a world-wide protest against the war in Iraq that drew about 5 million participants.  
The marchers thought themselves to be “good:” people for opposing the war.  
But they were trying to preserve the Hussein regime.  I wonder if any of the 5 million were Democrats.
He also never praised Putin.  
ISIS was financing its operations by selling the oil it had seized by running oil convoys into Turkey.  
Trump did acknowledge Putin’s role in stemming the flow with Russian air raids; and that we should be grateful for the help.  
Our pathetic president refused to bomb the oil convoys at all.  
I will have more to say about Mr. Trump and Hillary Clinton in future letters.
Dr. Wayne Roth
Roslyn Heights


  1. LMAO. This is the most ignorant rant siting convenient out of context quotes from non significant figures this foreign policy legal council and professor has EVER read. Dangerous ignorance, bordering on asinine. Please do the world a favor and get a better quality of education, “Dr.”

  2. I remember being in a LI firehouse and reading an application that was posted on their bulletin board and one question in particular. ” Are you a member of the Communist party or any other subversive group? Nuff said.

  3. You three are just refusing to believe the truth! All three should just take a flying leap out of our country. I’m glad I don’t know any of you personally. I would be ashamed to consider you a friend. You, “Browsing researcher” are “asinine”. And Mr. Delgado, I, for one, look forward to what Dr. Roth has to say about Mr. Trump and HILLARY CLINTON. Clinton is a disgrace to this country. Anyone who praises her should get their head out of the sand. Have a nice life all three of you, preferably out of our great country.

    • OH eat a bran muffin Grandma. You old racists and bigots have to make room for the new generations as we see through all the ugliness and hatred. Yes you will find bad in every race, color or creed but you mostly find good. Funny how the writer mentioned the Muslim religion being like communism because
      “It seeks to control every aspect of your life i.e. your sex life, the music you listen too, the books you read, etc.” wow, you mean the way Christianity does or any major religion for that matter. The Christians will have you believe they are different but they demand the same. The truth spreading fear has a motive behind it.

      • You comparing islam to Christianity only highlights your ignorance on both. Cut down on telling older generations what to eat and pick up a book.
        Dr Roth’s comments are based on facts. I’m tired of coming across leftists who burst a blood vessel when presented with truth.

        • What is wrong with what Name said about religion? All religions state how a person should live their lives. Sure Islam and Christianity don’t have similar practices, but they both requirements about how to live. Islam is totalitarian because it states how to live every aspect of a person’s life? Well so does Christianity, so you and the author of this article are the ignorant ones. And one more thing!!!!! Communism is anti-religion so Islam is nothing akin to communism.

    • Proud grandma, I completely agree with you. If these people are so unhappy with the leaders of this country, they should try to go and live in Venezuela !!!!! I am a legal immigrant in this country and agree completely with President Trump on hi immigration policies. I come from a European country that has been destroyed by Muslims and also by the stupid politicians that have run my birth country. I am sick and tired to hear about “ being politically correct” ! That is all CRAP !!!! There are no other country that are like the USA. And if all these jerks of liberals are embarrassed to be Americans, please leave ASAP. This amazing country will be so much better without you !!!

    • I have been mystified by how so many kiss up to the Clintons for so many reasons. Could we have Bill Clinton as Our first ever First ‘Gentleman’ in the WH?
      LMBO- laugh my brain out on that one.
      And due to Trump, so so many white supremist popped back out of their sanctuaries and the evangelicals compared to whom we have a much greater and profound concept of Our Creator. In their god we may not trust.
      As for rapist, most of those I see accused don’t look Mexican to me. On and on.
      Charles Samek

  4. i look forward to Dr. Roth’s future comments. Mr. Delgato apparently suffers from the mental disorder called liberalism. He should listen to Michael Savage’s radio show on N.Y.’s WABC, who has been talking about securing our borders, making English our official language to bring down the costs of the tower of babble and give us a identity, and explain our american culture as unique in all the world with it’s checks and balances written into our laws. he has been on the radio since 1994 and is author of many books of all topics of interest! As for the browsing researcher, he probably is a teacher at one of our local colleges or schools infecting our students with his global village mentality… and as for Rich De Leo, he thinks communists are OK, he should give the facts of any successful commie country that did not murder most all of their fellow citizen opponents in their quest to control things! liberals have ruined NY and that is why i just moved out of that crappy unconstitutional gun-free-zone-safe-act-state.

    • Thank you Frank. Sourced facts are far more helpful than unsourced insults. It must have taken you about two minutes to find that particular one. Perhaps more of us should do things like that. It might help keep America great.

    • If I had to guess, I’d say the good Dr. is spinning in his stool right now, having a tantrum and shouting, “fake news!” I think you gave it your best shot though, Frank. I second Tim, thanks for taking all of two minutes to help introduce Dr. Roth to learn news sources other than Tucker and Ann. Also Dr., are you 12? When you say, “My wife is an immigrant…” Looks like you have taken a page directly from DJT’s book. Gross. And Paul, what a unique and non-ignorant rant (yawn). I think we should make Navajo the official language.

  5. Dr Roth, great comment !!!! Liberals have such hate for Trump, that they would prefer, he fails on EVERY front, rather than acknowledging his successes!!!! It is sad and disgusting that liberals prefer that AMericans have to struggle to take care of their family and live in a uncertain and unsafe world, only because they hate that President Trump would succeed at doing so. This is the real liberal sickness of elitism.

  6. This is pathetic, racist, and lacking in facts. I’m not surprised to see something like this, though, because apparently facts are not important to people these days. Look up some statistics that don’t come from Fox News. Blind hatred of “liberals” does no one any good.

    • How is this racist? Muslims aren’t a race. Mexicans aren’t a race. Moreover, some random guy in Long Island has no power over them. Of course, you libs think you can just shut discourse up by screaming racist. No one’s falling for it anymore.

      • If that is what you think Bubba, then why all this criticism about Muslims? If neither has power over anyone, why fear them? Why all this rant about Muslims bring totalitarian? You think that we Muslims want global domination?

  7. What is wrong with what Name said about religion? All religions state how a person should live their lives. Sure Islam and Christianity don’t have similar practices, but they both requirements about how to live. Islam is totalitarian because it states how to live every aspect of a person’s life? Well so does Christianity, so you and the author of this article are the ignorant ones. And one more thing!!!!! Communism is anti-religion so Islam is nothing akin to communism.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here